Welcome to our New York Style Pizza! Our dough and salsa is made fresh in house daily! Our quality is 100% guaranteed

Guest Testimonials
Kristen T.

Excellent little place! So glad I stumbled on this gem of a locally owned and operated pizza place. We tried the pizza, chicken wings and cheesy garlic bread and everything was absolutely delicious! We will definitely order again and again.

Ruben G.

Absolutely Delicious food!!! Best chicken parm sandwich in town, hands down. The pizza is constructed masterfully: with a crisp and tasty crust and the perfect ratio of flavorful sauce to cheese and fresh toppings. Looking forward to trying the burgers. Strongly recommend this restaurant to anyone looking to satisfy their pizza cravings!

Joshlynn C.

I just try it for the for time and can say here in Milwaukee best pizza 🍕 ever, great taste (like NYC 🗽 pizza), always fresh straight out from the oven 🤤🤤 Excellent customers service, very friendly people 10+😉 And the chicken wings 😍 YOU HAVE TO TRY IT, FOR SURE

Contact Form

Margarita's Pizza
Pizza Calzones Wings Hamburgers Sandwiches Salads
Food Types
Vegetarian Options
Business Hours
Mon: Closed
Tue - Thu: 3:00 PM - 10:00 PM
Fri - Sun: 11:00 AM - 10:00 PM